Chip Scoggins: What if Vikings keep winning but Kyler Murray isn't the answer at QB?
Published in Football
MINNEAPOLIS — The topic of the day carried enough tension and big-picture priority that Kevin O’Connell, in the middle of an answer, reminded the assembled media that his team is 3-0.
“Long-term visions are great and I think you need them,” the Minnesota Vikings coach said, “but I want to make sure that day-to-day, hour-to-hour, minute-to-minute, we’re trying to win every football game we play. That’s never going to change.”
The illuminated question mark that hangs above their impressive start to the season is hard to ignore because, well, it involves the quarterback position, same as it ever was.
J.J. McCarthy’s future with the organization already was blanketed by doubt before Monday. The trade that sent him to the New York Giants resolved that issue but left a larger conundrum.
Kyler Murray has 14 games remaining to answer that question.
The Vikings once again will need to find a starting quarterback at season’s end when Murray’s contract expires.
Will it be Murray? A veteran free agent? A rookie selected in the draft?
My normal advice to people who obsess over the future is to just relax and enjoy the season. This situation is an exception.
The cleanest option would be for Murray to settle in and play at a level that screams: “Franchise quarterback. Don’t let him leave the building.”
Murray has played 70 snaps in a Vikings uniform. It hasn’t started well, but it’s way too soon to render a verdict. Give him more time running O’ Connell’s scheme to see if the fit works longer term.
The runway isn’t endless, though. O’Connell and new general manager Nolan Teasley will need clarity by this winter. That timeline creates urgency to formulate contingency plans.
A good record with suspect quarterback play would be the equivalent of no man’s land. That scenario would necessitate a new direction at quarterback but likely leave the team outside of a desirable spot to draft one.
Neither O’Connell nor the Wilf family, which owns the team, has any appetite for picking in the top five. The next quarterback class is considered deep, but a 3-0 start puts the Vikings on pace to pick behind several QB-needy teams.
The organization’s default setting historically has been baton passing between veteran quarterbacks who hold the spot for only a short stint. That’s why McCarthy’s arrival generated so much optimism. He represented hope, the idea of a true franchise quarterback being drafted and developed for the long haul.
If the Vikings ultimately feel compelled to start over again, it’s fair to wonder how McCarthy’s tenure will shape their decision. Would they desire an established veteran in free agency more than entrusting the future to another young quarterback?
The Vikings’ roster has been assembled to be competitive now and in the immediate future. That variable requires a certain standard from the quarterback position.
NFL quarterback is the hardest job in sports. Incredibly smart football people get it wrong all the time. Trying to predict how college quarterbacks will translate to the NFL is an inexact science because offenses are vastly different at the two levels.
That process is complicated by the fact that patience in the NFL can fit inside a teacup. Fans, owners, media and social media form a vortex of opinions and expectations.
O’Connell was asked if McCarthy’s experience and other examples of young quarterbacks struggling “scare” him about potentially dipping his toes in that water again.
“You’re always evolving and changing based upon the previous experiences, and I think that applies in this circumstance,” O’Connell said. “However we move forward, that’ll absolutely apply.”
It’s still speculation at this point. The picture should be clearer three months from now.
Monday’s news created an odd vibe. McCarthy was jettisoned, Murray was coming off a poor outing, yet the Vikings remain undefeated.
A lot of the season is left to be played. A related story will be moving along a parallel track.
____
©2026 The Minnesota Star Tribune. Visit at startribune.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.







Comments